He often compares himself, unfavorably, with his wife, whom he refers to in rhapsodic terms. “She’s, like, a saint,” he said. “She’s just an exceptionally good person.” He describes her family as “Marxist activists”; her brother is the late leftist historian Howard Zinn’s publisher, and her mother built a domestic-violence shelter in Bloomington in the seventies and ran it until her death, in 2017. Eisenberg and Strout have volunteered at the shelter, Middle Way House, and he credits his time there with giving him perspective on “the things that actually matter.”
Eisenberg likes trivia games, and agreed to be on “Millionaire” after learning that his winnings would go to a charity of his choice. He’d asked Giamatti to be his partner, and the day before, at the Sony Pictures lot, he’d spent an hour pacing around a trailer, analyzing the competition. “You have more general knowledge than other actors,” he told Giamatti. “You read. I’ve never seen an actor with a book.”
“Yeah, but I read mysteries,” Giamatti said. “Though I was an English major.”
“I might say ‘hermeneutics’ when I’m answering,” Eisenberg said. “Even if it isn’t relevant.”
“See, I don’t even know what hermeneutics are,” Giamatti said.
“That’s the genius,” Eisenberg said. “No one does.”
The two made it to the final round, and decided to walk away with half a million dollars. Eisenberg gave his half to Middle Way House. He’d enjoyed himself, he said at breakfast, though he was reluctant to admit it. He told me that he’d once tried seeing a Freudian analyst who, after a few sessions, diagnosed him with a complex called arousal disgust. Eisenberg was quick to clarify that “this was not a sexual thing” but, rather, “this idea that I will like things and then immediately feel disgusted.” He added, “Like, how talking to you makes me feel good about myself, which of course means that in about an hour I am going to feel incredibly embarrassed by it.”
His life is full of such equivocations, moments when he feels he must atone for his privilege. Banner attends private school and also frequently volunteers alongside his parents. Last summer, after Eisenberg received an award at a Czech film festival, he and his family drove to Ukraine to work at a children’s art camp for a week, spending one night in a bomb shelter.
The apotheosis of Eisenberg’s urge to carbon-offset the advantages of fame came last December, when he gave one of his kidneys to a stranger. He got the idea a decade earlier, after listening to a podcast about “altruistic organ donation.” “It felt so clean to me,” he said. He sent off a saliva sample to a company that made donor matches, but he heard nothing back.
Later, a doctor he met explained that he didn’t have to wait—he could just walk over to the N.Y.U. hospital and offer up an organ. That fall, Eisenberg was starring in an Off Broadway one-man show that he’d written, so he scheduled his operation for the first available weekend after it closed. Initially, those around him didn’t understand his decision—“I thought, This is maybe putting generosity on steroids,” his father, Barry, told me—but his family came around. “By the end of his time in recovery, his sister and I had inquired about beginning the process, too,” his mother, Amy, said. Kieran Culkin told me that he plans to hold on to both his kidneys. “But, when you hear Jesse’s reasoning, you gotta admit, Oh, shit, he’s right,” he said. “He’s, like, ‘Put me under and cut me open and take an organ from me!’ He’s terrified of everything, but he’s not nervous about that. It’s weird.”
