A cybersecurity journalist recently uncovered an online service claiming to sell scans of more than 150 million driver’s licenses and millions of other IDs, including passports. Reportedly among them was the driver’s license of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. The images appear to have been siphoned from an identity verification vendor. And every month seems to bring another breach that exposes our personal information and puts us at risk of identity theft and fraud.
Yet policymakers, including those in Florida, want us to surrender even more sensitive information to age verification systems that scammers routinely hack. Tallahassee has already passed an age verification law that is being fought in the courts, and state Attorney General James Uthmeier has already proposed even more restrictions.
Indeed, age verification proposals, sold as a way to protect kids online, are spreading worldwide, rom Australia’s under-16 social media ban to various U.S. proposals, that would effectively require ID checks to use online platforms or any phone or computer app. Each one puts more personal information at risk of hacks and breaches.
The lawmakers behind these mandates, however, will not pay for those breaches. Most don’t seem to have considered the real costs their policies inflict on average internet users. And why should they? They can always fault the companies they deputize for any resulting costs and failures. The legislator who wrote the mandate gets to say all they wanted was to keep kids safe. The company that gets breached takes the blame.
Meanwhile, the people who do bear the costs are ordinary users. Identity theft already costs Americans an estimated $43 billion a year, and the average data breach costs an American business over $11 million. Those costs will only climb if even more Americans are forced to provide identifying information to access much of the internet, creating a ripe target for hackers. And the numbers miss the personal toll on victims, adults and kids alike: damaged credit and the anxiety of having one’s identity stolen and misused.
Breaches don’t just enable fraud. They also threaten anonymous speech. Much of the internet is accessed anonymously or pseudonymously. Many social media platforms allow users to speak and receive information through accounts that are not tied to their real names. Most apps, from The New York Times to Signal to Pokémon Go, don’t require users to show ID.
If you must show ID to speak online, your identity is one breach away from being made public. Consider the 2025 breach of Tea, a dating safety app for women that had users upload selfies and IDs to prove who they were. The breach exposed 13,000 government IDs and selfies, 59,000 other images, and more than 1 million private messages about sensitive issues. Outed women were harassed online, and Tea ceased to be a place where women could speak honestly about dating safety. Under an age verification mandate, that kind of exposure would no longer be limited to users who chose to take that risk.
The trade doesn’t buy the safety it promises. Australia’s own experiment demonstrates that failure in action.
After the country banned kids from holding social media accounts, many simply evaded enforcement. Instead of staying on platforms with parental controls and algorithms that at least try to limit some types of inappropriate content, many kids moved to platforms without those protections. Others faked their ages, so platforms treated them as adults. In the UK, their media regulator charged with overseeing their Online Safety Act recently concluded that the law made “no significant change in the proportion children encountering harmful content.” Good intentions weren’t enough to keep kids safe online.
If that failure concerned policymakers, they did not show it. Instead, lawmakers are doubling down, as seen in the UK and Australia, where they are giving safety regulators more powers and pushing for more intrusive age verification requirements. Some are even considering banning virtual private networks, or VPNs. Age verification advocates and politicians don’t want to grapple with these costs. They would rather blame tech companies for all social ills.
Privacy and freedom online are an unacceptable price for a policy that fails kids and turns everyone’s data into a target. Before lawmakers require the next ID database, they should ask who pays when it leaks. So far, the answer is all of us.
David Inserra is a fellow for Free Expression and Technology at the Cato Institute.
