The Trump administration is seeking to make it more difficult for employers to sponsor workers for green cards, offering sweeping potential changes to the federal program that governs the steps people must take to hire foreign employees for permanent residence in the United States.
Its plan covers a lot of ground. The most seismic change, though, is arguably the elimination of a rule that allows employers to circumvent the time-consuming labor market test when hiring nurses and physical therapists, two crucial occupations the government has long recognized as suffering from labor shortages.
The full proposal, recently published by the Department of Labor, would broadly alter the permanent labor certification (PERM) program in a few significant ways. Employers would be prohibited from filing a PERM application within two years of laying off U.S. workers in “the same or similar occupation.” (Current law mandates six months.) If such a layoff occurs after a PERM application has been filed, employers would be obligated to consider laid-off U.S. workers over “a significantly broader timeframe”—one extending through the adjudication of an immigrant’s petition. It would also mandate longer recruiting periods and an expanded approach to job advertising.
The PERM program already presents significant bureaucratic hurdles to employers—as it stands, its rules are meant to ensure that “no able, qualified, and available U.S. workers who are willing to accept the permanent job offer” and that hiring someone from abroad “will not adversely affect the wages and working conditions of similarly employed U.S. workers.” The process, as a result, is strict and cumbersome.
Schedule A, the exemption, thus allows employers to bypass the standard process when hiring for certain vital roles experiencing nationwide shortages. “We have determined there are not sufficient United States workers who are able, willing, qualified, and available for the occupations listed below on Schedule A and the wages and working conditions of United States workers similarly employed will not be adversely affected by the employment of aliens in Schedule A occupations,” the regulation reads. The intent was to make a burdensome law more nimble and responsive.
So why the change? “The Department likewise cannot justify continuing to waive recruitment for U.S. workers as it no longer possesses evidence that there is a nationwide shortage of U.S. workers able, willing, qualified, and available to work as physical therapists or professional nurses,” the proposal says, “as required for their placement on Schedule A.”
The data do not appear to support that contention. “There is a projected 8% shortage of registered nurses (RNs) in 2028. By 2038, the shortage is 3%,” which amounts to a shortage of 108,960 full-time nurses, the National Center for Health Workforce Analysis noted in a recent report. Notably, “these projections assume that historical patterns of attrition, graduation, and labor force participation remain the same over the forecast period.” The American Physical Therapy Association, meanwhile, forecasted a 3.3 percent shortfall for 2037.
In practice, the proposed change—which is open for comment through January 19—would require healthcare employers to run a red-tape-ridden bureaucratic gauntlet to fill critical medical roles. “Run” may not be the appropriate word when considering how much waiting is involved—a mix of exertion and atrophy. It’s plausible, in other words, that this would exacerbate an existing labor shortage in an industry where time is in short supply. Is that worth the tradeoff?
