Welcome to the most wide-open Democratic presidential primary in two decades.
Party operatives looking at the potential field of candidates (and often trying to get a job with said candidates) do not see a juggernaut waiting to bully the rest of the field. Instead, they see a “Big Five”: Former Vice President Kamala Harris, California Gov. Gavin Newsom, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Sen. Jon Ossoff and former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.
But of those five, it’s unclear if three of them — Harris, Ocasio-Cortez and Ossoff — will end up running at all.
The result is a (very) early race with absolutely no clear frontrunner, a far cry from former President Joe Biden’s pole position in 2020 or former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s clear early dominance in both 2008 and 2016.
“There’s no clear frontrunner, and even high name ID isn’t necessarily going to translate to success,” said Josh Schwerin, a Democratic strategist with extensive presidential campaign experience, adding: “The eventual nominee is going to have to salvage the terrible reputation of the Democratic Party, and the primary is shaping up to be a very healthy debate about who is the best leader for that challenge.”
Most close observers of the race do not expect candidates to start entering the race in earnest until March. Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) is widely expected to be the first person to enter the contest, though he has said he won’t make a final decision until after the holidays. At a recent Democratic-run gathering in Denver, most of the rumored potential candidates seemed to kick the tires, sheepishly declaring that they should be the chosen leader.
And of the five leading contenders, it’s unclear whether a majority even want the job.
Ossoff has publicly ruled out the prospect and committed to serving his full six-year term, citing his desire to spend time with his young family. Ocasio-Cortez has a choice between running for president or running for the U.S. Senate seat held by incoming Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, with many Democrats in New York expecting she’ll prefer the latter. And Harris ― who leads most early primary polls ― has not publicly indicated an announcement timeline, though nearly a dozen of her former aides are now on her payroll, according to independent reporter Zohreen Shah.
Earlier this week, former second gentleman Douglas Emoff said Harris is currently reflecting and will share more in her own time.
“She was really heartened to listen, to hear what people had to say, to support different types of candidates up and down the ticket, not just at the national level, but at the state and local level,” Emhoff said at an event in Los Angeles. “All these offices matter. And that’s what she spent her time doing. And now she’s going to reflect and make a decision, and you’ll all hear it when you hear it.”
The other two leading candidates, Newsom and Buttigieg, are seen as near-certain to run. Buttigieg announced earlier this week he will release a book in January. Newsom has said he won’t run if Harris does — which most Democrats have interpreted as an implicit prediction that Harris will not. Both are seen as flawed leaders, with questions about Buttigieg’s ability to appeal to Black and Latino voters and murmurs that Newsom’s stock peaked a year ago.
A second tier of candidates is moving more aggressively towards a bid. A top aide to Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) recently left Giffords — the gun control group named after his wife — to advise him directly again, while Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro gave a foreign policy-focused speech in Philadelphia on Friday.
But right now the most active efforts are coming from draft groups not directly affiliated with the candidates they support.
At least half a dozen groups (and growing) aimed at drafting their favorite Democrat to run have popped up over the last few weeks, including one for Harris. These draft organizations for Harris, Ocasio-Cortez, Buttigieg, Ossoff, Maryland Gov. Wes Moore, Khanna and former Rep. Rahm Emanuel (Ill.) are gathering names and emails that have the potential to spawn more robust organizing and volunteer infrastructures for their preferred candidate if they decide to jumpstart a bid.
And they are full steam ahead, with or without buy-in from their principal.
Some groups, like “Team Pete PAC” are encouraging supporters to engage potential voters with host house parties and fundraisers, with an emphasis on community service, said Jennifer Holdsworth, the former campaign manager of Buttigieg’s DNC chair run, who will help lead the PAC alongside other allies of the former South Bend, Indiana, mayor.
And despite what’s bound to be an elbows-out primary, they’re not hoarding their resources — if Buttigieg isn’t the nominee, their group is happy to share them with whoever the nominee ends up being, Holdsworth said. She believes that most other Democrats are more prone to support over sniping these days anyhow.
“I think that the field is going to be extraordinarily exciting. I’ve been in and around Democratic politics for around 25 years, and I’ve not yet seen the type of excitement at the beginning of the process this much,” Holdsworth told HuffPost. “I’m really hearing people talk about how excited they are right at the beginning, and I’m not hearing in real life a lot of sniping against any of the candidates. I think everybody is just completely moved that there’s so many people that may or may not be interested in it.”
“Ready for AOC” is also building a list of potential volunteers.
“Winning won’t be easy, but it will be worth it,” the group says. “AOC won’t have the backing of billionaire donors eager to line the pockets of candidates they know they can control. If we want AOC to win in 2028, the work starts now, and it starts with us.”
The “Run Kamala Run PAC” will host its first virtual kickoff event this Saturday, headlined by Chris Walton, former Chair of the Democratic Party of Milwaukee County, Wisconsin. The group is touting Harris as a frontrunner despite media skepticism.
“The media narrative is wrong. People like Kamala Harris, and they want her to run again,” said Matthew Taylor, president and treasurer of Run Kamala Run PAC, in a statement announcing the event. “More than 6,000 people signed up before we were even a PAC. Now we’re making it official.”
