“When a Witness Recants,” a new documentary from the director Dawn Porter and the executive director Ta-Nehisi Coates, premièred today on HBO. It examines the case of the Harlem Park Three, in which three teen-agers were convicted of the notorious 1983 murder of another teen, DeWitt Duckett, in Baltimore and imprisoned for decades, and later exonerated after a key witness recanted his testimony. The documentary feature is based on Jennifer Gonnerman’s reporting on the case, from 2021, for The New Yorker.
Gonnerman spoke with that witness, Ron Bishop, who was fourteen when he became the key witness in the case of Duckett’s murder, which took place at their West Baltimore junior high school. Bishop told Gonnerman that he had been coerced by police to name three innocent fellow-students—Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins, and Andrew Stewart—as the perpetrators of the crime. Each of them was sentenced to life in prison. For nearly four decades, Bishop was tormented not only by the knowledge that he had helped send three teens to prison but also by the fact that the person he suspected had actually killed Duckett went unpunished. Bishop ultimately decided to recant his testimony, and, in 2019, all three men were freed after the prosecutor Lauren R. Lipscomb reinvestigated the case. Lipscomb, speaking about the prosecutorial misconduct that she uncovered, told Gonnerman, “This is absolutely the worst that I have seen.” ♦
