More than three years into a $242.7 million overhaul of U.S. Highway 19, the construction company rebuilding the highway is accusing Pinellas County of contributing to delays that county officials say have put the project more than two years behind schedule.
Representatives of Johnson Brothers Corp. appeared before the Pinellas County Commission on Tuesday to oppose a plan to hire another contractor to complete some of their work. They contend that design problems and lengthy waits for revised construction plans have hampered the project.
Commissioners voted 4-3 to approve a $10 million increase to an existing utility repair contract with QRC Inc., approximately $4.5 million of which is intended for work associated with the highway reconstruction.
U.S. 19 carries commuters, shoppers and commercial traffic from St. Petersburg through some of Pinellas County’s largest employment and retail centers. In 2024, the Florida Department of Transportation estimated that an average of 105,000 vehicles traveled the highway just north of State Road 580 each day.
Johnson Brothers was awarded the construction contract in 2022. Work began the following spring and is expected to conclude in 2030, according to FDOT’s project website.
The state is rebuilding the highway from State Road 580 to north of County Road 95, adding two interchanges and frontage roads intended to improve traffic flow while preserving access to businesses.
Motorists face roughly four more years of construction along the corridor, with businesses continuing to operate amid lane closures and changing traffic patterns. Part of what’s holding up construction is a water main.
Pinellas County Utilities Director Jeremy Waugh said crews must relocate approximately a mile of one of two major water lines feeding the county’s water system. Road construction in the affected area cannot proceed until the utility work is complete.
In addition, county officials want to address a leaking valve near Evans Road while crews are in the area. Negotiations over how to complete the work and what it should cost have dragged on for months.
In its recommendation to commissioners, county staff cited concerns about the quality and progress of the utility work performed under Johnson Brothers’ contract. Officials believe hiring QRC would give the county greater control over construction and help expedite the project.
Johnson Brothers representative James Charles traced some of the construction problems back to March 2025, when the company raised concerns about the water main’s pipe restraint system. Revised plans arrived more than five months later, with further revisions following in January 2026.
Charles said the contractor encountered similar problems with a drainage structure. Six months passed between the company notifying the county’s engineer of the issue and receiving a response.
Johnson Brothers has identified six issues it considers major contributors to construction delays, putting the associated costs at $20.7 million.
The company already has crews and equipment on the highway. Charles argued that the county could work with FDOT to authorize Johnson Brothers to proceed under its existing contract rather than bring in another company.
The contractor wanted commissioners to examine the potential cost difference before making that decision.
“Taxpayers deserve a clear price comparison,” Charles wrote in correspondence submitted Monday. “JBC priced the revised Evans additions at approximately $2.64 million. Explain how that scope compares with the County’s $4.5 million US 19 allocation.”
The county’s allocation includes water main bypass operations, utility relocations and other work associated with the highway. The two estimates have not been established as covering identical work.
Commissioner Vince Nowicki questioned Waugh about what QRC would charge compared with Johnson Brothers. Waugh explained that the county had obtained pricing from QRC but had yet to reach a negotiated price with Johnson Brothers through FDOT.
Charles asked commissioners to defer the vote pending an independent review.
Several commissioners entertained that possibility, suggesting they revisit the contract in December after having more time to examine the dispute. But waiting another month could carry a hefty price tag of its own.
County staff estimates that further construction delays could result in claims against the county of approximately $230,000 per week.
Johnson Brothers contracts directly with FDOT, not Pinellas County. If the contractor seeks compensation from the state for delays caused by the county’s utility work, FDOT could pass those costs on to the county.
Waugh said his department was already negotiating about 70 claims associated with the highway project. He could not guarantee that further claims would materialize but warned that the utility work needed to begin within 30 days to avoid the risk of another delay.
Commissioners had to consider the county’s ability to respond to water main breaks elsewhere in Pinellas. Previous work on U.S. 19 and emergency repairs had nearly exhausted QRC’s existing contract. Without increasing its spending limit, the county risked losing the ability to dispatch that contractor for emergency repairs.
Commissioner Kathleen Peters moved to approve the increase, with Commissioner Rene Flowers seconding the motion. The vote remained unsettled for several minutes as commissioners questioned whether postponing the decision would leave the county exposed to additional financial claims.
County staff expects the Evans Road work and associated water main bypass operations to take six to eight months.
Waugh told commissioners the highway project was already more than 800 days behind schedule.
“Everyone that lives up there wants this road done,” Waugh said. “I’m trying to get us out of the way.”
This content provided in partnership with stpetecatalyst.com.
