Benzinga and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below.
A family tie from the past resurfaced with a demand that had no clear place in the present.
Karen, 27, called “The Ramsey Show” from Huntsville, Alabama, after inheriting $419,000 from a woman who became an important part of her life. She said the situation turned into a moral question after a man tied to her past insisted he deserved a share.
“My stepmom passed away… I was her life insurance beneficiary,” Karen said. She said her stepmother told her before her death that she would receive the money.
Don’t Miss:
Karen’s stepmother was never legally tied to her family, but became a steady part of her life, especially during college when they lived together and grew close.
The man now pushing for more money was once married to Karen’s mother for a short time and has a long history with the woman who died, spanning more than two decades. Even so, they had been apart since around 2012 or 2013.
“The lady that died left life insurance to the person she wanted it to go to,” personal finance expert Dave Ramsey said. “End of story.”
“They’ve been apart 15 years, give or take,” he said, questioning how any claim could still stand. Ramsey pressed Karen to separate the emotional confusion of the family dynamic from the actual decision that was made before the woman’s death.
See Also: Earn While You Scroll: The Deloitte-Ranked #1 Software Company Growing 32,481% Is Opening Its $0.50/Share Round to Investors
In the last five years of her life, the woman allowed the man, Karen’s former stepfather, to move back in as his health declined, taking care of nearly everything from meals and bills to doctor’s appointments.
Karen received $419,000 through life insurance, while he was named beneficiary of a 401(k) worth about $135,000.
Co-host John Delony said the split spoke for itself. “She picked some money for him too,” he said.
Karen said the pressure was hard to deal with, even though she and her husband lived separately from the situation.
“You do not owe this guy a dime. Not morally, ethically,” Ramsey said. “As a matter of fact, quite the contrary. It would be immoral and unethical to give him any of it because the lady that died left it to you intentionally.”
Ramsey’s advice in this situation is clear — the money went exactly where it was meant to go. But cases like this also raise a bigger question: what should you do when you come into a large, unexpected sum?
